When I Was Your Man

“Sarah?“

Karma stared at him with an unreadable expression. “You really cheat on someone like me with SARAH? I mean, with all those options you had, Mr. Rockstar?“
“Like I said,“ Matt tried to defend himself, “I didn’t plan on anything, It doesn’t make it better but…“

“Thanks for being honest with me, Matt. Really. That’s been keeping me from sleeping ever since we talked. Now I finally know what I did and what you did back then, and I guess we should have talked about that at some point.“
“At some earlier point,“ Matt offered.
“Yeah, at some earlier point.“

"Anyway, I think it's all going well, don't you think?" Matt tried to change the subject. He hoped she would agree to leave it at that. There was nothing he could do now anyway besides being angry at himself, and he already was.

"Yeah it is, and honestly I'm glad we're all here. And that we're good," she replied with a smile.
"We are?" he asked hopefully.
“Yeah, I guess we are. I can’t blame you anymore, can I? You’re so different now.“
“Yeah, I changed a lot.“

“Out of all the guys I think you changed the most.“
“What’s so different now?“ Matt asked. He noticed himself that he had changed. Still, he wanted to know how Karma knew. And what she thought of it.

“Everything. Your hair, the beard, the Rev tattoo… But I reckon you’re not asking about your outward appearance, are you?“

Matt chuckled at the mentioning of his hair. If you knew… he thought. “You used to say what you wanted to say and do whatever you wanted to do. You know, you took whatever it was that you wanted. And you never thought about how it affects me or the band or whatever.“

She’s talking about us, isn’t she?

“And that… was so much better?“ Karma let out a chuckle. “You always needed a little push into the right direction, though, like a truth and dare game.“
Matt didn’t think clearly anymore. He knew she was talking about how they first happened so many years ago, and it was true. Without that, he would have never made his move. And now? That was the push, right?

God, I wish I was drunk. It was so much easier back then, he thought. Karma’s little hand landed on his arm, and goosebumps spread over his body. Shit. This was not how he imagined the evening to go, especially not after admitting what he did back then.

He bent over and closed the distance between their bodies. Her heavy breaths were music to his ears. Matt’s lips crashed on hers, and a wave of ecstasy overcame him. Her hands tangled in his hair, and Matt felt like he was twenty-four again, and thinking he could have it all.

He opened his mouth a little, and Karma got the hint. Her tongue slipped inside his mouth and started massaging his. Fuck, she tasted so amazing. Matt scooped her up and placed her onto his lap. A wild moan escaped his throat as her warm core met his semi-hard erection, which of course didn’t stay just semi-hard after that.

His hands moved to squeeze her ass. Fuck, so perfect. She moaned into the kiss, and Matt loved the sound of it. He let his fingers slowly creep up her thighs, knowing she would go insane in mere seconds.

Karma broke the kiss and started biting his neck, causing him to growl. He let his hand slip underneath her panties without a warning. She was so wet for him. He got up and took her with him, then threw her onto his bed.

In a heartbeat, he removed her panties, then pulled her t-shirt over her head. She laid there naked on his bed, and he couldn’t help but inhale sharply. “Gotta love the view of that,“ he let out, then pushed a finger into her tight organ.

His action was rewarded by a groan. Matt started pumping his fingers in and out of her, and his mouth traveled to her perfect breasts. He licked and sucked at her sweet skin until he felt her walls tighten. She was close.

The hand in his hair tried to push his head down to where she wanted him, but Matt had other plans. He let out a chuckle. “You thought I’d make it so easy? Don’t forget I know all about your likes,“ he husked. He needed to make it memorable for both of them, that much he knew.

He yanked his t-shirt off his body, then ripped it apart. For once he was thankful that it was a bad quality. I should have played like this the very first attempt I got, he thought to himself. But back then, he didn’t feel as comfortable as now. Matt tied both of her wrists to the bedposts, one on the left, the other on the right.

“Much better,“ he commented with a dirty grin. He loved tying her up. He let his fingers run up and down her folds teasingly as his head made its way down south, placing kisses on her skin.
Finally, he reached his destination. Matt placed a kiss on her clit, then took the swollen nub into his mouth. The sounds she was making were heavenly. He pushed in his fingers once again, building up an agonizingly slow pace. His tongue circled around the bundle of nerves.

He was glad he entered the house again, seeing as they undoubtedly needed the condoms. She would feel so good around his cock. Matt let out a moan, and his lips vibrated against her lower lips. She was getting awfully tight again, and louder, too. He loved how close he could get her with such little effort.

“Shh, you don’t wanna wake up the others,“ he whispered, then pulled out his fingers. “Seriously? You’re doing this again?“ She whispered in frustration. “Shut the fuck up or I won’t let you come at all,“ he hissed. She loved his dominant part.

With that, he got up to grab a condom, then pulled off his underwear. His erection sprung to life, glad it was not restrained by any fabric anymore. He quickly rolled on the condom, then finally rammed his throbbing member inside of her. “Ugh fuck Matt,“ she moaned and rolled her eyes.

He gave her some seconds with minimal movement, then worked up a steady rhythm. It felt so good to be inside her. Karma slung her legs around his body and let escape all sorts of sounds, but she made sure they were quiet enough not to wake the others.
With each thrust, Matt felt her walls clenching as he got her closer. His hands grabbed her breasts as he felt his own orgasm building up. “Come for me,“ he commanded, and her body jerked uncontrollably as her walls practically milked his member.

“Shit,“ he breathed out, and she grinned at him. “Yeah, you could say that.“ Karma wiggled her hands out of the ripped t-shirt, then sat up. Matt understood that she wanted to leave, but he didn’t want her to.

“Hey, what if I wanted to repeat that later?“ He pouted.
“I really don’t know, Matt. I didn’t plan for this to happen, unlike you, Mr. I'm Bringing A Condom Just In Case,“ she said with a wink.
“I, uh…“

“It’s okay. I thought about buying some, too. Go to sleep now. We have a long day ahead of us. Let’s not make it awkward, okay?“
Matt nodded, not particularly happy with her not staying over although he'd already gotten much more than he thought he would. “Good night,“ he whispered. “Sleep well,“ she retorted.

Matt turned around in his bed with a smile. The sheets smelled like her, and like sex. He would have no problems going back to sleep.

Notes

Hey guys, here's an update for you :) I'll be updating again on Sunday I hope, then I'll be away for two weeks sadly. Hope you all liked the update :)