Matt’s P.O.V
We thought Val and Gena were pissed off when they came home last night, we had another thing coming this morning. Gena had gone to work, we’d heard her complaining about being late and not having time to finish getting ready, before she stormed out of the house, slamming the door behind her. Turns out girls get cranky when they don’t get any action, too.

But Val apparently didn’t have to work today, and she wanted to come down and play with Brian and me.

“Don’t you want to know how your girls are doing?” She smirked, walking around the basement, occasionally dusting something off with her finger. Brian and I were busy drinking our water and eating the small meal she had brought down for us. It was the first time we had eaten in days and we had ignored almost everything else she said, but that peaked our interest “I thought so,” She chuckled when she noticed the two of us looking up at her with big eyes.

“What have you done to them?” Brian growled, jumping to conclusions, so was I, but I hadn’t said anything.

“Nothing,” She told us confidently, holding her hands up in defence “They’re both still at home, Erin thinks you’re missing, she’s worried sick,” She cooed to Brian before turning to me “And Hannah, well, she’s a mess, she’s angry, sad, frustrated and confused, why would you cheat on her Mattie? Why would you do something like that after all this time? She doesn’t know what to think, was everything you told her, ‘promised’ her, a lie?”

“You crazy bitch!” I seethed “Why the fuck would you do that?!”

“I need her weak,” She purred, standing in front of me “I need her vulnerable enough to let me in, to be her shoulder to cry on and eventually… she’ll let me make her feel good,”

“Don’t you touch her!” Brian growled “Either of them, you leave them alone,”

“Why?” She asked “Don’t you like seeing, or even thinking about a girl being with another girl?”

“When it’s the two most beautiful women in the world together,” I smirked “Yes, but not when it’s you,” She narrowed her eyes at Brian, turned on her heel and walked into the corner, returning a moment later with a golf club and smiled at me.

“You don’t think that, do you Mattie?” She asked, her tone sickly-sweet, I wanted to puke “You used to love it when I was with a girl and you got to watch, didn’t you?”

“No!” I barked at her “Get over yourself, Valery. Everything that happened with us is in the past, and the thought of it now makes me sick,”

She said nothing, but the sound of a crunch, followed by me roaring in pain filled the room next and I looked down to the source of the pain, my shin. She had moved too fast, swung the golf club into the air and down onto my bone, successfully breaking it by the feel of things.

And by the time Val left us alone for the rest of the day, I had a busted lip to match my broken shin bone and Brian had a shiner of a black-eye, but I had a feeling that was only the beginning.
~~~~
Hannah’s P.O.V
“So what the fuck are we doing about this?!” I yelled, slamming my hands down on my kitchen table “Matt and Brian have both just vanished off the face of the earth and we have no idea who took them!” I rubbed my hands over my face and groaned loudly.

“Hannah,” Erin sighed, grabbing my hand and pulling me into the chair beside her “Just calm down, take a deep breath and let’s think about this,”

“We need to think about this with clear minds,” Zack spoke up “We got rid of everyone who wanted to kill the two of you, you dealt with the Gena and Val situation,” He almost cringed at the thought “Who wanted to get to you so badly that they would hurt Brian and Matt?”

I felt my eyes widen to the size of frying pans and my mouth fell open as I turned to Erin, who was turning to me, her face the exact same as mine.

“You don’t think…” She trailed off.

“THOSE BITCHES!” I roared, standing from the table once again, whipping around and knocking a glass and a stack of bridal magazines off of the counter and onto the floor with a smash and a smack “They bribe us into making things okay with them, then, they pretend to be our friends, that they actually care about what we’re going through, but they’ve had our men this entire time?!”

I was furious, I was seeing red, I couldn’t believe this shit. It was all making perfect sense though, the girls who are obsessing over us, the girls who want us more than anything in the world, apparently, get rid of the men who have us in the hopes that we fall for them. I was starting to panic as I thought about all the possibilities of things they could have done to Matt and Brian, my instinct was taking over and my body wanted to run away from the situation so that’s what I started to do. I barely made it to the kitchen door when Jimmy grabbed me around the waist and lifted me back to the table, sitting me back beside Erin. I dropped my head onto the table and allowed Erin to rub soothingly soft circles on my back and remind me to breathe, whispering soothing words to me.

“Alright,” Zack spoke again “Pieces of this puzzle are coming together and it looks like Val and Gena may have Matt and Brian, but how do we find out if we’re right?”

Slowly, I raised my head off of the table and looked at everyone.

“I have a plan,”
~~~~
Ten minutes later, I was ready. My hair was half-way to sex hair, my lips were painted with red lipstick, I wore a sexy night-gown, black with lace, black heels on my feet and wrapped my long coat around me and tied it into place.

“Alright,” I said, clapping my hands to get everyone’s attention again “I’m going to go over there and see if I can get anything out of Val, I’ve already text her and Gena is working late tonight, Val’s getting the wine out,”

“What are you going to do?” Erin asked, stepping closer to me as she nervously chewed her bottom lip “If we’re right about this she could hurt you too,”

“She isn’t going to,” I reassured her “If we are right about this, then she wants me safe and alive,
so… kiss me,”

“What?”

“Kiss me, like you mean it, like we’ve – like we’ve just been getting ready to fuck each other senseless,”

Slowly, Erin stepped up to me, pushed herself onto her tiptoes ever so slightly so she could reach the height I am in heels and crashed her lips against mine. Now, I know what you’re thinking; this is not the time to be getting it on with your girlfriend. But you want this to be believable, don’t you?

Once I was sure my lipstick was smeared enough, I pulled away from Erin, and her eyes were filling with lust as her eyes raked up and down my body.

“Slap her,” Johnny said from the sofa, and we all turned to look at him “What?” He asked “If you want Val to believe the two of you got into a fight so bad that you had to rush over there, we need to go all out on this,”

I thought about what he was saying, and he was right, it wouldn’t be like me to yell a little and storm out on Erin, something bad had to have happened.

“Okay,” I sighed, preparing myself for the hard slap Erin could give.

“Are you serious?” She asked “I don’t want to hurt you,”

“You won’t,” I lied through my teeth, she would hurt me and she needed to. I closed my eyes and felt E standing in front of me again, I braced myself and a second later, I heard the smack before I felt it, it was so hard that I almost lost my balance.

“You alright?” She asked, grabbing my arms and looking into my eyes with concern.

“I’m fine,” I squeaked, my hand raising to my cheek to rub the area the burning was coming from “Alright, so, let’s go over this one more time,” I turned to Jimmy who had his laptop set up on the coffee table and the speakers were plugged into it and he walked over to me with a small, clear device between his fingers.

“This will allow us to hear everything you and Val say to each other, it will pick up any other sounds too, we won’t hear them though until you come back and we go through it in great detail, but if they’re there, we will pick something up,” I nodded and let Jimmy fix the piece into my ear
“You won’t hear anything we say, the last thing we need to be doing is distracting you,” There was a loud clap of thunder from outside, the house lit up from the lightening and then the rain started to batter down on the windows.

“You gonna be alright?” I asked Erin, she never did do well with storms, she just grabbed a hold of Johnny and nodded quickly.

“You’re going to go over there, you’re a mess, crying and looking like…” Jimmy trailed off and gestured to my body “This, but you and Erin got into a fight, things were said and she slapped you, so you needed to get away, you needed Val,” I nodded again “Once you work some things out, you only have an hour to do what you have to do, Erin will call you and apologize for being so stupid, tell you she was wrong and beg you to come home,” Erin laughed and I had to giggle
“If they have the guys, the next part of the plan will happen tomorrow, you lure them back over here, tell them you want to make up for everything that’s happened over the past few days and offer to cook dinner and have a nice romantic night, just the four of you-“

“We slip them a little something, put them somewhere safe for a while, get Brian and Matt back before torturing the shit out of them,” Erin smiled deviously.

“Before putting them six feet underground,” I finished.
~~~~
Val’s P.O.V
Hannah had text me to say that she needed to see me, and asked if it was alright for her to come over, of course, I told her it was fine, finally, I would have her all to myself while Gena worked, I got out the good wine and set out two glasses before freshening myself up while I waited for her.

As I was teasing the brush through my hair, the doorbell rang.

“Finally,” I smirked to myself in the mirror before hurrying down to the front door and throwing it open dramatically.

The rain was pouring down on her, her umbrella was dripping over her as she tried to shield herself from the rain, there was another clap of thunder and she jumped a little and sniffed, that’s when I realised she was crying.

“Oh my God, what happened?” I gasped, pulling her into the house and taking her umbrella from her. She looked amazing. Her hair was all tousled, her coat was tight around her waist, showing off her shape to me, her shoes made her legs look like they went all the way up and from the looks of it she wasn’t wearing much under her coat. My eyes finally made their way back up to her face and I noticed the reapplied red lipstick and the slight smudging she’d tried to fix around the outside of her mouth, also, the bright red handprint on her left cheek.

“Erin and I got into a fight,” She sighed, untying her coat and walking through the house and into the living room where everything was set up.

“Well take a seat,” I gestured to the large, comfortable sofa “Tell me everything,” I sat beside her and opened the bottle of wine, filling our glasses with a generous amount of the red liquid.

“After everything that’s been happening recently, all I wanted was a little fun of my own since Matt’s off having so much of it,” She sniffed “And after getting E into it, we were on the sofa in my living room and I started to… travel south, if you know what I mean,” She shifted, crossing her legs and leaning back a little with the glass in her hand, her coat slipped off her shoulder a little, revealing that she was wearing just a sexy item of sleepwear “Then she moaned her name, while I pleasured her with my tongue!” She exclaimed. She leaned forward again, put her glass down and fully removed her coat “Rebecca,” She spat, like it was venom.

“The woman Matt’s sleeping with?” I asked, knitting my eyebrows together in mock concern, but she looked at me in confusion.

“Yes,” She said quietly “How did you know that?” Fuck. I tripped up over my own lie already.

“You told me her name, silly,” Wrong. She had only told me ‘her’ first initial.

“Oh, yeah,” She giggled, taking another sip of wine “Anyway, I accused her of cheating on me too, with the same whore who stole Matt from me, she told me I was imagining things, that she didn’t moan her name, she moaned mine, when I told her she was lying she called me crazy, I called her a bitch and then…” She trailed off and I could stop my hand as it reached out to her face and cupper her red cheek.

“She hit you?”

“Slapped me,” She nodded “It was my own fault though I suppose,”

“Why would you say that?” I asked.

“Because!” She exclaimed, pulling away from me and standing up in front of me before she started to pace the room “I wasn’t enough for Matt!” She cried “I’m obviously not going to be enough for her either!” She was getting too loud, I knew they would hear her at this volume.

My worst fear came true when I heard the faint sound of Matt and Brian yelling her name, but she didn’t seem to notice, she just looked at the floor and let her tears flow.

“Sometimes, I swear I can still hear him saying my name,” She whispered. Oh the Irony.
I jumped to my feet and moved to her, pulling her into my arms so she could bury her face in my neck and cry freely, which she did, while I whispered soothing things to her. I couldn’t stay mad at her for the other night, it wasn’t her fault all of this was happening. My plan was just going to take longer to play out now.

“If I were him,” I said softly, pulling away to look at her at arms-length “I’d never have left such a beautiful,” I pecked her lips “Caring,” Kiss “amazing,” Kiss “Woman like you,” She leaned in to kiss me again when her cell started ringing in the pocket of her coat. She moved over to the sofa and picked it up.

“It’s Erin,” She said, frowning.

“Answer it,” I told her with a smile “Hear what she has to say,”

“Hey,” She breathed into the phone as she pressed it to her ear “I’m sorry too,” She was starting to choke up “You want me to come home?” Damn “Okay, I’ll be there soon, okay, I love you too, bye,”

“She wants you to go home?” I asked sadly and she nodded.

“We’ll do something again soon, alright?” She tied her coat around her body again, gave me a quick kiss and hurried out the door.

I was going to have to teach these guys to stay quiet when I have company.
~~~~
Hannah’s P.O.V
I’d gotten home about twenty minutes ago. Val’s had gone better than I’d expected and I’m almost certain I heard something coming from the basement, but Jimmy – and all of his technology – would confirm my suspicions.

I’d gone up to my room, removed all of my makeup, tied my hair up in a messy bun on top of my head and changed into one of Matt’s cut-off’s and a pair of his boxers too. This was the closest I could be to him right now.

“What have we got?” I asked, grabbing my mug of tea and sitting on the couch beside Erin.

“You should be an actress,” Zack chuckled, trying to make light of the situation “She was putty in your hands,”

“What can I say? Dramatics run in my family, we’re all a bit over the top sometimes,”

“Hannah!” Came through the speakers. My voice and Val’s voice had been cancelled out and now we were listening to the background noise.

“It’s two voices,” Jimmy confirmed “It’s them,”

I turned to Erin who was smiling widely, I couldn’t help but smile with her.

“We’ve got ‘em,” She said, leaning in to press her lipst against mine softly.

Notes

So, the girls have their plan in action to take down Val and Gena! Is it all going to go smoothly and work out well? Will they get their guys back?
Stay tuned for more from E to find out!!
My amazing co-worker and bestie who I've been writing with now for a long, long time! Love ya girl!

- LMV x